While doing research recently, I came across a recipe for Ice Cream Bread on Taste of Home’s website. It had a four-out-of-five star rating.
I glanced at it and remembered I had flagged an email about this recipe from Taste of Home’s public relations folks. It caught my eye then because, besides sounding interesting, the recipe makes a mini-loaf. Readers always are asking me how to pare down recipes or make smaller versions of some of their favorite foods.
But when the recipe turned up again on a Facebook post by Milwaukee Journal Sentinel food editor Nancy Stohs, I knew I couldn’t ignore it any longer. Though I must admit my first thought was, this is just plain odd. You’re supposed to eat ice cream cold. And aren’t there better uses of ice cream, which in my house is a real treat? And, besides, who wants to waste good-quality “full-fat” ice cream (as the recipe recommends) making bread?
But I just had to try it.
The bread is made by stirring together ice cream, sugar and self-rising flour. That’s it. (Don’t fret if you don’t have self-rising flour; you can make your own as noted in the recipe.)
I tested it using two different ice creams: Southern butter pecan crunch and triple brownie. Both were the deluxe versions of store brands, and both were on sale. I didn’t want to waste $4 on a pint of premium ice cream when I could get nearly a half-gallon for $2.50.
An Internet search turned up all sorts of comments and recipes that used a variety of ice creams. Some even added fruit, such as blueberries and bananas, to the batter, with good results.
The first thing you need to know: The ice cream needs to be softened so it mixes easily with the flour. Scoop out what you need, place in a bowl and let it sit out a good 30 minutes. The rest is gravy: Mix the two with sugar, spoon the batter into a loaf pan sprayed with nonstick spray and then bake.
Easy as pie.
Although mine seemed to take longer to bake, the end results were fine. The bread tasted sweet. I expected the butter pecan bread to taste the best, but it had a floury taste. The triple brownie tasted much better.
A coworker noted that one use for this bread would be to serve it with more ice cream.
Tempting, isn’t it?