Black undies or white? It was a choice writer-director Zack Snyder confronted while making "Sucker Punch," a female action-fantasy starring Emily Browning as a gun- toting, sword-swinging killer deceptively named Babydoll.
She dispatches zombies and robots with the kind of brutality that made Snyder’s mostly male “300” a hit in 2007, but she also wears a thigh-high skirt that, as viewers will discover when “Sucker Punch” opens today, can be rather revealing.
The underwear question involved more than just aesthetics. As it turns out, Snyder wanted the color to downplay any titillation, not increase it.
“I did make a concession to say, ‘Let’s make her underwear black,’” Snyder said. “Otherwise I’m noticing it too much. If it was white, you see it. But those are the kinds of things we did, because I didn’t want the movie to be about that.”
It’s a small but important point that underscores the tricky nature of a movie whose sexual politics are as multi layered as its plot. A three-tiered narrative that unfolds in an insane asylum, a brothel and the escapist fantasies of its beleaguered heroine, “Sucker Punch” is a visual blend of pulp comics, steampunk and video-game violence, all shot in Snyder’s signature heightened style. One minute its female characters are invincible warriors, the next they’re chattel. Almost always, they are thoroughly rouged and suggestively dressed.
“It was difficult, at first, to convince the studio, not because it’s about all-female action characters but because it was so different,” said Snyder’s wife, Deborah, who helped produce the film for Warner Bros. “You usually pitch them a set of comps” — that is, clips of comparable movies — “but there were no comps for a movie like this. That was both exciting and scary.”
What has been done before is the revved-up mix of female-driven action and overt sexuality. The 1970s television show “Charlie’s Angels” was famous for strategically jiggling its heroines; Russ Meyer’s 1965 cult classic “Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!” featured women with aggressive personalities and large bosoms. Angelina Jolie’s Lara Croft character often wore combat boots and little else.
“You have to recognize that we are making a genre movie, a movie that has elements of, say, Japanese anime,” said Carla Gugino, who plays the brothel’s mother hen, Madam Gorski. “In ‘300,’ the men wore less clothing than we’re wearing! It is absolutely embracing that women can be sexy, strong, smart, all of those things.”
“Sucker Punch” features five young actresses cast somewhat against type. Browning (Babydoll) starred in the kids’ film “Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events.” Abbie Cornish (Sweet Pea) played John Keats’ love interest in the costume drama “Bright Star.” Jamie Chung (Amber) recently had an eye-candy role in Adam Sandler’s “Grown Ups.” Jena Malone (Rocket) is known for indie films such as “Saved” and “Bastard Out of Carolina.” And Vanessa Hudgens (Blondie) is a dimpled tween idol from Disney’s “High School Musical” franchise.
For “Sucker Punch,” they practiced martial arts, trained with assault rifles and worked out under Logan Hood, a former Navy SEAL who also wrangled Snyder’s actors on “300.” Malone, for one, piled 10 pounds of muscle on her 5-foot-6-inch frame and eventually pushed her rack dead-lift weight to 300 pounds.
“I get incredible work as an actor, but no one ever says, ‘When I look at you, I see someone who can kill 40 men with heavy artillery.’ Never had I had anyone instill that belief in me,” Malone said.
Snyder wanted his female characters to embrace certain traditional sexual archetypes – “the nurse, the French maid, the schoolgirl,” he said — and simultaneously take control of them. Such archetypes are common in movies with explicit sexual content, he notes, yet “Sucker Punch” seems destined to cause some hand-wringing even though it contains no sex scenes at all.
“The most dangerous place to go, I think, with female sexuality, is when people are conscious of their own sexuality and it becomes a tool,” Snyder said. “The power of it, when they’re aware of it — that’s dangerous. Society is not into that, for whatever reason. I thought we had a sexual revolution and everyone is cool with that. But apparently it’s still a hot-button issue.”
LADY KILLERS: THE TOUGH 10
The female action heroes of “Sucker Punch” are unusual in Hollywood, but not altogether new. Here are 10 of moviedom’s toughest ladies, from Western gunslingers to alien killers.
Joan Crawford: In the gender-bending 1954 Western “Johnny Guitar,” she wore the pants and packed the pistols, while co-star Sterling Hayden mostly strummed.
Tura Satana: As the leader of a girl gang in Russ Meyer’s 1965 sexploitation classic, “Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!,” she literally kills a man with her bare hands.
Sigourney Weaver: As Ripley in 1979’s “Alien,” she turned a distressed-damsel role into a tough-as-nails character who survived through three more films.
Lori Petty: She played the title role in 1995’s “Tank Girl,” the poorly reviewed adaptation of the sci-fi comic books. Ahead of its time?
Bridget Fonda: She starred as a deceptively pretty assassin in 1993’s “Point of No Return,” though Luc Besson’s original 1990 French version, “Nikita,” remains a landmark among action chick flicks.
Milla Jovovich: The cat-eyed actress has helped make the pulpy “Resident Evil” franchise, based on a video game, a dependable seller at the box office since 2002.
Uma Thurman: Her otherworldly beauty made her an effective choice in Quentin Tarantino’s ultraviolent “Kill Bill” movies (2003-04).
Noomi Rapace: In 2009’s “The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo,” the Swedish actress originated the role of Goth-punk bisexual sleuth Lisbeth Salander. Fans are waiting to see if Rooney Mara can fill her boots in the upcoming American version.
Chloe Grace Moretz: In last year’s “Kick-Ass,” she played the 11-year-old superhero Hit Girl, racking up the highest body count and cursing a blue streak.
Angelina Jolie: One of the few widely successful female action stars, Jolie recently took the lead in the CIA thriller “Salt,” a role originally written for a man. Her “Lara Croft” franchise is set for a relaunch; her replacement has not been announced.