The Olympian Logo

Supreme Court to hear case on downed livestock | The Olympian

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • Customer Service
    • About Us
    • Buy Photos and Pages
    • Contact Us
    • Plus
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Newsletters
    • Newspaper in Education
    • Subscribe
    • Subscriber Services
    • Archives

    • News
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Databases
    • Death Notices
    • Education
    • Local News
    • Military News
    • Obituaries
    • Politics & Government
    • State
    • Traffic
    • Watchdog
    • Weather
    • Opinion
    • Cartoons
    • Editorials
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Opinion Columns
    • Submit a Letter
    • Sports
    • College
    • High School
    • Mariners
    • Preps Stats
    • Seahawks
    • Sounders
    • UW Huskies
    • Politics
    • Living
    • Announcements
    • Food
    • Health & Fitness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel
    • Entertainment
    • Arts & Culture
    • Comics
    • Puzzles & Games
    • Events Calendar
    • Horoscopes
    • Movies
    • Restaurants
    • Outdoors
    • Fishing

  • Classifieds
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Place An Ad
  • Mobile & Apps

National

Supreme Court to hear case on downed livestock

Michael Doyle - McClatchy Newspapers

    ORDER REPRINT →

November 07, 2011 02:58 PM

WASHINGTON — California's ban on the commercial slaughter of downed livestock will come before the Supreme Court on Wednesday, in a case that pits state vs. federal power.

Gruesome videos and gory facts drove California lawmakers to impose the ban on downed-animal slaughter. Justices, though, will be focused on something a little more antiseptic: whether federal law pre-empts the 2008 state law.

The Obama administration says it does, siding with the National Meat Association in challenging California's prohibition.

"If enforced," Solicitor General Donald Verrilli Jr. argued in a legal brief, the California law "would have a significant potential to create confusion and confrontation between those federal inspectors and state officials."

SIGN UP

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The Olympian

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

California lawmakers, allied with Humane Society of the United States activists who exposed the slaughter of downed animals at a San Bernardino County facility, claim that states have the authority to act on their own.

"Cruelty to animals, in particular, has traditionally been regulated by the states, going back nearly 400 years to the Massachusetts Bay Colony," noted J. Scott Ballenger, an attorney for the Humane Society and other groups.

Ballenger, in his legal brief supporting California, cited the 17th century colony's prohibition, written in the language of the time, against "any Tirrany or Crueltie towards any bruite Creature which are usuallie kept for man's use," as well as less archaically spelled modern state regulations.

The state law in question governs the handling of downed livestock, sometimes called non-ambulatory. These are animals that are so sick or weak that they can't stand on their own. The California law bans their commercial slaughter. Federal law similarly bans the use of downed cattle, but permits the use of downed swine and sheep.

But the case, called National Meat Association v. Harris, and the hourlong oral argument Wednesday morning, concerns much more than a turf struggle. The outcome could tilt the balance in a perennial struggle between state and federal authority.

It's for this reason that Alaska, Washington and 11 other states are siding publicly with California, while the U.S. Chamber of Commerce is siding with the meat association and livestock industry.

The states want to be able to pass their own laws on a variety of issues without federal action constantly upstaging them. As protection, they want the court to sustain what they call the "long-held" policy that presumes state laws aren't pre-empted unless the federal law explicitly says so.

The Chamber of Commerce, a frequent critic of state laws it deems too onerous, argues from the other side for a more limited presumption against pre-emption.

"The chamber ... is keenly interested in ensuring that the regulatory environment in which its members operate is a consistent one," attorney Kenneth Geller, who's representing the business group, argued in a legal brief.

California's Los Angeles-based deputy attorney general, Susan K. Smith, will represent the state Wednesday, matched up against Minneapolis-based lawyer Steven Wells, who represents the meat association, and an Obama administration lawyer.

Their abstract arguments will have roots in a gritty undercover investigation by the Humane Society of the United States. In January 2008, the organization released a video that depicted brutal treatment of livestock at the Hallmark Meat Packing Co. and the Westland Meat Co. Inc., in Chino, Calif.

The video showed non-ambulatory cows, unable to stand or walk without assistance, being kicked, electrocuted, dragged with chains and rammed with forklifts.

"Footage also showed some workers trying to get ... cows to stand by spraying pressurized water into their noses to simulate drowning," the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals subsequently recounted.

The resulting outcry triggered the largest beef recall in U.S. history, covering more than 143 million pounds of meat.

After the recall, the California Legislature toughened the state's law governing slaughterhouses. The new law prohibited using non-ambulatory pigs, sheep, goats or cattle; the law further required that the downed animals be euthanized.

The National Meat Association successfully argued before Fresno, Calif.-based U.S. District Judge Lawrence J. O'Neill that the Federal Meat Inspection Act pre-empted the state law. The federal law permits the slaughter and sale of downed swine and sheep if they've passed safety inspection.

ON THE WEB

Supreme Court

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

Consumers wary of turkey burgers after recall

Food safety bill: Spinach gets new oversight, but not beef

Humane Society and agribusiness increasingly at odds

Follow Michael Doyle on Twitter

  Comments  

Videos

Colorado man recounts killing mountain lion with his bare hands

More than 20 shots fired in fatal police shooting of California rapper

View More Video

Trending Stories

Woman who died in Thurston County wreck has been identified

February 18, 2019 04:59 PM

Where’s the Lacey Albertsons? It’s gone, now that senior-housing project is underway

February 18, 2019 02:53 PM

Local business owner says she is running for Lacey City Council

February 18, 2019 02:03 PM

‘Uncertainty’ about whether snow is coming back to the lowlands this week, or just rain

February 18, 2019 10:20 AM

Survived the snow? Olympia will offer free downtown parking to celebrate ‘Big Melt’

February 19, 2019 02:02 PM
Local display advertising by PaperG

Read Next

Police dismiss tip Smollett, 2 brothers together in elevator

Celebrities

Police dismiss tip Smollett, 2 brothers together in elevator

By DON BABWIN Associated Press

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 19, 2019 10:05 PM

Chicago police have investigated but dismissed a tip that on the night "Empire" actor Jussie Smollett reported being attacked by two masked men he was in an elevator of his apartment building with two brothers questioned in the probe.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The Olympian

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE NATIONAL

Trump wants California to pay back billions for bullet train

Business

Trump wants California to pay back billions for bullet train

February 19, 2019 09:18 PM
Judge OKs suit aimed at halting Obama library in Chicago

Business

Judge OKs suit aimed at halting Obama library in Chicago

February 19, 2019 05:18 PM
Despite bill’s demise, W.Va. teachers to strike for 2nd day

Nation & World

Despite bill’s demise, W.Va. teachers to strike for 2nd day

February 19, 2019 04:59 PM
Latest: City lawyer welcomes decision on Obama library suit

Nation & World

Latest: City lawyer welcomes decision on Obama library suit

February 19, 2019 03:12 PM
Choupette, Karl Lagerfeld’s fashionable feline, will inherit part of his large fortune

National

Choupette, Karl Lagerfeld’s fashionable feline, will inherit part of his large fortune

February 19, 2019 02:51 PM
Teen rescued when her accused abuser gets stuck in snow and calls 911, Oregon cops say

National

Teen rescued when her accused abuser gets stuck in snow and calls 911, Oregon cops say

February 19, 2019 02:42 PM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

The Olympian App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Contests-Promotions
  • Vacation Hold
  • Rewards
  • Pay Your Bill
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Photo Store
  • Archives
Advertising
  • Information
  • Place a Classified
  • Local Deals
  • Place an Obituary
  • Today's Circulars
  • Special Sections
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story