Vanguard exposes a flaw in women's savings

Vanguard says many women may be undermining their own savings progress without realizing it. A new survey from the investment giant found that although most women feel confident about their ability to save consistently, a large percentage still keep their money in accounts earning interest rates below inflation.

That means balances may continue growing on paper while their real purchasing power quietly declines over time. The findings expose what financial experts call a hidden disconnect between saving habits and savings allocation, especially during a period of elevated living costs.

The issue carries added weight for women, who continue to face wage gaps, caregiving responsibilities, and lower average retirement balances than men, making every dollar saved increasingly important to long-term financial stability and flexibility.

Vanguard survey finds 46% of women earn less than 3% on savings

More than 70% of women in the Vanguard survey reported feeling confident in their ability to consistently save money, Vanguard reported in its May 6 press release.

Yet beneath that confidence lies a hidden problem. Among the 51% of women who keep their non-retirement savings in checking or savings accounts or in cash, 46% hold their money in accounts earning less than 3% annual interest, according to the Vanguard survey.

Another 26% told researchers they did not even know what interest rate their savings accounts were generating, which suggests the problem could be even wider than the headline number indicates.

That gap matters more than it might seem on paper because the Consumer Price Index climbed 3.3% year-over-year in March 2026, Bureau of Labor Statistics data confirmed. When your savings earn less than the inflation rate, every dollar you set aside is slowly losing the ability to buy what it could when you deposited it.

"A lot of times people just don't have money in the right place because of inertia," said certified financial planner Carolyn McClanahan, founder of Life Planning Partners in Jacksonville, Florida, and a member of the CNBC Financial Advisor Council.

Competing priorities drain women's savings before goals are met

Nearly half of the women surveyed by Vanguard identified financial security as their primary savings goal, but the survey data showed that competing demands routinely pulled money away from that objective before it could compound meaningfully.

47% of women used their savings at least once during the past year for something other than the goal they originally set, the Vanguard survey found. Among that group, 14% dipped into their savings four or more times for unplanned expenses, increasing the damage to long-term financial security.

More Vanguard:

• Vanguard challenges the S&P 500 as a one-stop strategy
• Vanguard exposes the account costing parents $25K
• Vanguard says 30% of millionaires feel broke, but it can be fixed

When asked about their top financial regrets, 27% of respondents cited spending money on things they did not need, 18% said they waited too long to start saving for an important goal, and 14% said they helped family or friends financially when they should have protected their own savings first, according to the Vanguard survey.

One in five women reported having no savings at all outside of retirement accounts, the Vanguard data revealed. For those women, a single unexpected expense could mean turning to credit cards or personal loans, which carry interest rates that magnify the original cost of the emergency.

Klaus Vedfelt/Getty Images

Trusted guidance and education could shift women's savings behavior

The survey asked women what factors would make them more confident about moving their cash from low-yield accounts into higher-earning alternatives, and the responses pointed toward a clear information gap rather than a lack of motivation.

35% of respondents said a trusted recommendation would increase their willingness to switch, 30% wanted more accessible financial education, and 29% said guidance from a certified financial professional would help them make that transition with confidence, according to the Vanguard report.

Generational differences in what drives savings confidence

• Forty-three percent of Gen Z respondents, a higher proportion than any other generation, said a trusted recommendation would make them more confident about changing their savings approach, the Vanguard survey found.
• Millennials, at 37%, were the generation most likely to say that additional financial education would make them feel comfortable moving to a high-yield savings option, the survey showed.
• Eighty-three percent of mothers were significantly more open to changing their savings strategy, compared with 70% of all women surveyed, when presented with the possibility of receiving more education about available options, Vanguard reported.

"I work with many women, particularly mothers, who are juggling competing priorities and often putting their own financial goals on hold," said Tiana Patillo, a CFP and financial advisor manager at Vanguard, in the firm's release.

She noted that Vanguard believes closing the gap starts with clear, accessible information that helps women understand their goals and commit to a plan.

Low-yield savings accounts cost women more than most realize

The national average savings account yield is just 0.38% as of the FDIC's April 20, 2026 update. That means a woman with $10,000 in a standard savings account would earn roughly $38 in interest over the year, while inflation erodes approximately $330 of her purchasing power during the same period.

High-yield savings accounts from online banks and brokerages currently offer annual percentage yields in the 3.5% to 4% range, which brings savers much closer to matching or exceeding the inflation rate. The difference between 0.38% and 4% on a $10,000 balance over five years translates to roughly $1,800 in additional interest, before compounding.

"Savings are a crucial part of everyone's holistic financial strategy, and yet the survey found a clear disconnect between women's overarching financial goals and how and where they save," said Sonia Fraher, Head of Cash Management at Vanguard.

Certified financial planner Lazetta Rainey Braxton, founder and managing principal of The Real Wealth Coterie, pointed to money market accounts as another accessible option that often pays interest comparable to high-yield savings accounts and offers check-writing or debit card access for additional flexibility, CNBC reported.

What women can do to close the gap, starting now

Women still face a stubborn pay gap, costly caregiving responsibilities, and retirement balances roughly half those of men. These structural forces are unlikely to reverse on their own. That makes every savings choice women make today carry extra weight.

Three moves financial planners consistently recommend

Move idle cash to a high-yield account: Traditional savings rates rarely keep pace with inflation, which means cash sitting in low-yield accounts steadily loses purchasing power, according to CNBC.

Automate transfers on payday: Routing money into savings before discretionary spending begins removes the friction Carolyn McClanahan described earlier as "inertia." The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau calls this approach "pay yourself first."

Keep a separate emergency fund: Holding emergency cash in a different account creates "a psychological barrier" against dipping into long-term savings for short-term shocks, CFP Cary Carbonaro of Ashton Thomas Private Wealth told CNBC Select.

None of these closes the pay gap. But each one increases the share of every saved dollar that actually compounds, which, given the headwinds, is where the most reliable progress comes from.

Related: Vanguard exposes the account costing parents $25K

The Arena Media Brands, LLC THESTREET is a registered trademark of TheStreet, Inc.

This story was originally published May 10, 2026 at 4:17 PM.